In the dynamic world of energy, staying ahead of regulatory changes is essential for businesses and stakeholders. One of the most significant developments has been Bill C-59, a legislative measure designed to balance environmental goals with economic realities.  By understanding the implications of Bill C-59, companies in the energy sector can better navigate the evolving regulatory landscape and adapt to new requirements.

Bill C-59 brought substantial amendments to Canada's Competition Act, specifically targeting greenwashing practices. These changes empowered the Competition Bureau to investigate and enforce actions against unsubstantiated environmental claims.  The Bureau has broad authority to initiate investigations based on complaints from consumers, competitors, and whistleblowers. This increased scrutiny highlights the necessity for businesses to rigorously substantiate their environmental claims.

Bill C-59 has garnered significant attention from professionals in the energy sector, particularly for its stringent measures against greenwashing. Conor Chell, Partner and National Leader of ESG Law at KPMG in Canada, has provided valuable insights into the implications of this legislation. In the article Bill C-59: Balancing Green Goals with Economic Risks, Chell emphasizes the importance of substantiating environmental claims to avoid penalties. He highlights that the Competition Bureau, empowered by Bill C-59, can impose administrative monetary penalties (AMPs) up to $10 million or three times the value of the benefit derived from the claim, or 3% of the company’s global annual gross revenue, whichever is greater. This underscores the need for businesses to adopt robust risk mitigation strategies and ensure their environmental claims are backed by credible evidence.

Chell also discusses the broader impact of Bill C-59 in Bill C-59: From Investigation to Inquiry. The Bureau's authority to investigate and enforce actions against unsubstantiated environmental claims is a critical step towards enhancing accountability. Chell points out that the heightened scrutiny on environmental claims will likely lead to increased collaboration between companies and regulatory bodies. Businesses are encouraged to engage legal counsel early in the process to ensure compliance with the new legal requirements and avoid potential reputational damage.

By understanding and adapting to these changes brought on by Bill C-59, businesses in the energy sector can navigate the regulatory landscape more effectively and maintain their credibility in the market.

The impact on the Energy Industry

The impacts that Bill C-59 has brought to the industry have been significant and far-reaching. The penalties for non-compliance are severe, and the Energy industry is under heightened scrutiny. Companies are now focusing heavily on tangible actions and measurable results in their sustainability efforts, carbon footprint reduction, and renewable energy initiatives. All reports are now backed by credible data and thorough documentation to avoid penalties. The increased accountability brought on by Bill C-59 has begun to drive innovation within the industry, as companies are now eager to collaborate more closely with regulatory bodies to ensure compliance. This shift is also influencing investment trends, with a growing emphasis on sustainable practices and technologies

The amendments also broadened the scope for private action against greenwashing. Consumers and organizations have now expanded their rights to challenge misleading claims, either by filing complaints directly with the Competition Bureau or bringing actions in court for damages. This increased accountability means companies must be more vigilant in their marketing practices.

To mitigate risks, companies should review their ESG disclosures to ensure compliance with the new legal requirements. Engaging legal counsel early in the process can help avoid potential legal repercussions and reputational damage.

Bill C-59 is not just a regulatory change; it is a call to action for the energy sector to lead in environmental integrity. This legislation challenges companies to go beyond mere compliance and embrace a culture of transparency and accountability. By proactively adopting robust environmental practices and substantiating their claims with credible evidence, companies can build stronger trust with consumers and stakeholders. This shift presents an opportunity for the industry to innovate and set new benchmarks in sustainability, ultimately driving positive change and fostering a more responsible and competitive market. The future of the energy sector depends on its ability to adapt, innovate, and lead in this new era of environmental accountability.

Please note this publication presents an overview of the investigation and enforcement proceedings for deceptive marketing practices under the Competition Act. It is for informational purposes only and is not a replacement for legal advice. If you need guidance, please contact KPMG in Canada’s ESG Legal Risk and Disclosure team to explore how we can help you navigate your legal needs.

Corporate summary

KPMG in Canada's full suite of ESG, legal, technical, tax, audit and advisory services can equip you with the tools for confident navigation of the ever-evolving energy sector, ensuring a future that's both resilient and sustainable. Tailored, measurable, and transparent, our approach can set the industry benchmark for excellence, Let’s connect.